
Your supplier stopped replying. The deposit wired three weeks ago. The "production photos" never arrived. The WeChat is silent and the Alibaba account has been "temporarily suspended." You're not the first person this has happened to — about 1 in 200 first-time China sourcing engagements ends in some form of fraud, and the rate is higher for buyers who skipped supplier verification. The good news: with the right steps, in the right order, in the first 30 days, you have a real chance of recovery. The bad news: most buyers do them in the wrong order and lose that chance.
Key Takeaways
- Move within 7 days. Your recovery odds drop sharply after the first week as the scammer dissipates funds, closes accounts, and erases digital traces.
- Don't accept "let's settle it amicably" from a non-responsive supplier. Insincere settlement offers are usually stalling tactics designed to convert your case from criminal fraud (which Chinese police investigate) into commercial dispute (which they don't).
- File a police report in China. Chinese police will investigate criminal fraud where the victim has clear evidence of intentional deception. They will not investigate ordinary commercial disputes. The framing of your report determines which bucket you fall into.
- Documentation is everything. Save every email, WeChat conversation, payment record, photo of products/specs sent, contract, and inspection report. Without this paper trail, neither police, banks, nor lawyers can help.
- Engage a Chinese lawyer early. A China-licensed attorney can pursue criminal complaint, civil action, asset preservation orders, and bank-fund tracing in parallel — the combination is what produces actual recovery.
First, Confirm It's Actually Fraud (Not a Misunderstanding)
Before initiating an expensive recovery process, rule out non-fraud explanations. Some suppliers go silent for legitimate reasons that will resolve in 5–10 days:
Chinese national holidays (Spring Festival, May 1, October 1 Golden Week) — many factories shut down completely for 5–14 days, with the lead person traveling without WeChat access.
Factory medical or family emergency — small factories often run on a single English-speaking sales contact whose absence freezes communications.
Internet or VPN issues — particularly in inland provinces; sales contacts who use Western tools (WhatsApp, Gmail) sometimes lose access during regulatory enforcement campaigns.
Indicators that silence is fraud, not absence:
- The supplier has stopped responding on all channels (WeChat, email, phone, Alibaba) simultaneously
- The Alibaba storefront has been suspended or removed
- The supplier never sent any production evidence (photos of materials, work-in-progress, or in-line inspection)
- You paid a deposit and the supplier's tone changed to evasive or hostile before disappearing
- The supplier asked for "additional fees" (mold, certification, urgent fee, customs fee) shortly after the deposit
- The factory's registered address shows no actual factory when checked via Baidu Maps street view or a local visit
If the silence pattern matches the second list, treat it as fraud and start the timer.
Common Mistake: Sending increasingly desperate messages to the supplier. Each message tips off the scammer that you've noticed, gives them time to liquidate the bank account, and may erase WeChat or email evidence (Chinese WeChat allows participants to delete messages from their side). Once you suspect fraud, stop messaging the supplier and start documenting.
The First 24 Hours: Document Everything
Before doing anything else, preserve the evidence. Once you escalate, the scammer may delete accounts or block you, taking the documentation with them.
Capture in this order:
1. WeChat conversations. Take screenshots, with date/time stamps visible, of every conversation thread with the supplier — including sales contact, factory manager, anyone you spoke to. WeChat has a "favorite" / "save" function; use it.
2. Emails. Export the full email thread (with headers) to PDF. Don't forward — the original headers contain authentication data that matters in fraud cases.
3. Payment records. Bank statement showing the wire, MT103 confirmation from your bank, screenshots of any fintech transaction confirmations.
4. Contract and PO. Original signed contract (if any), all PO documents, all invoices.
5. Product photos and specs. Everything you sent the supplier (designs, CAD, samples) and everything they sent you (samples, "production photos" — even fake ones are evidence of intent to deceive).
6. Alibaba records. If the supplier was on Alibaba, screenshot their full storefront, Trade Assurance status, and any Alibaba dispute records before the storefront disappears.
7. Supplier identity. Business license image (if you have it), Unified Social Credit Code, registered Chinese name, registered address, legal representative name.
Save all of this to a single folder, organized by date, with a one-page summary document on top stating: parties, amounts, key dates, current status.
This documentation set is what every subsequent step depends on. A police report without it goes nowhere. A lawyer without it can't advise. A bank recall request without it gets denied.
Days 2–7: Run the Bank Recall Path in Parallel
While preparing the police complaint, run the bank-side recovery path simultaneously. Two channels matter:
Channel 1: Your sending bank. Contact your business banking relationship manager (not the call center) and report the wire as fraud. Request:
- A SWIFT recall message be sent to the recipient bank
- The MT103 reference for the original wire
- Internal escalation to the bank's fraud department
The recall has a real chance of success only within the first ~5–7 business days after the wire — once funds are spent or moved within China, recall becomes nearly impossible. Banks know this and act quickly when given the right paperwork.
Channel 2: The recipient bank in China. The receiving bank (Bank of China, ICBC, etc.) cannot freeze funds based solely on the buyer's complaint — Chinese banking regulations require either a court order or a police request. But the receiving bank can be put on notice that the receiving account is involved in disputed funds, which can slow further outflows.
The way to engage the receiving bank is through your Chinese lawyer or police complaint — not directly. Buyers who try to email the receiving bank's customer service themselves get nowhere.
Days 3–10: File a Police Report in China
This is the single most important step, and the one most overseas buyers do wrong or skip entirely.
Why filing in China matters. Filing a police report in your home country (US, EU, etc.) typically goes nowhere. The fraud occurred in China, the perpetrator is in China, the funds are in China, the evidence trail is in Chinese jurisdiction. Foreign police lack mechanism to investigate. Filing in your home country is fine for insurance purposes, but doesn't drive recovery.
Where to file in China. The relevant authority is the Public Security Bureau (公安局) with jurisdiction over the location of the criminal act. For most factory fraud cases, that means the PSB in the city where the supplier is registered or operates. Examples:
• Shenzhen Municipal Public Security Bureau (深圳市公安局) — Cyber Crime Investigation Division for online fraud cases
• Guangdong Province Public Security Department (广东省公安厅) for cross-jurisdiction cases
• City-level economic crime divisions (经济犯罪侦查支队) for fraud above certain thresholds
The case threshold matters. Chinese criminal fraud (刑事诈骗) under the PRC Criminal Law typically requires the amount lost to exceed a regional threshold — commonly RMB 5,000 (~USD 690), and in some provinces RMB 10,000–30,000 for case acceptance. Below this threshold, the case is treated as a civil dispute, which the police won't investigate.
Frame the report correctly. This is critical and frequently botched. The report must establish criminal fraud, not commercial dispute:
• Emphasize that the supplier intentionally created false representations to induce payment (e.g., promised production that was never started, sent fake "in-progress" photos, claimed to be a manufacturer when records show they were a shell)
• Cite the deposit as the fraudulently induced transfer
• Reference the disappearance / silence as evidence of intent (not a normal commercial breakdown)
• Provide the documented evidence package as supporting material
Reports framed as "the supplier didn't ship the goods" or "they didn't fulfill the contract" get categorized as commercial disputes and closed without investigation. The same facts framed as "the supplier intentionally deceived me to obtain my deposit, then disappeared" get investigated as fraud.
Expert Tip: A Chinese lawyer can substantially improve the police report's reception. They know the local PSB's preferred format, the case-acceptance thresholds in that jurisdiction, the language that triggers criminal vs civil categorization, and the names and contact information of the relevant detectives. The lawyer's fee for drafting and submitting the report is typically RMB 5,000–20,000 — small relative to the amount in dispute on most cases.
Days 5–14: Engage a Chinese Lawyer in Parallel
The lawyer's job is broader than just the police report. A China-licensed attorney can pursue:
1. Civil litigation in Chinese court — separate from the criminal complaint. If criminal investigation is delayed or declined, civil action can still recover funds.
2. Pre-judgment property preservation order (诉前财产保全) — the Chinese court can freeze the supplier's bank accounts, real property, and other assets up to the disputed amount, before the case is decided. This is often the actual leverage that produces a settlement.
3. Asset tracing — Chinese lawyers have access to court databases, business registry data, and (with court support) bank records that let them follow where the funds went.
4. Criminal enforcement coordination — even after the police accept the case, prosecutorial follow-through often requires the victim or their lawyer to push.
5. Negotiated settlement — once police investigation is underway and assets are frozen, the scammer often becomes interested in returning some or all of the funds in exchange for case withdrawal.
Cost expectations for Chinese legal representation. For straightforward fraud recovery cases:
- Initial case assessment: RMB 2,000–5,000 (often credited toward retainer)
- Police report drafting and submission: RMB 5,000–20,000
- Civil suit filing and pre-judgment preservation: RMB 20,000–80,000 (depends on case value and complexity)
- Court fees: ~1–2.5% of disputed amount (refundable if you win)
- Success fee on recovered amount: 10–25% (negotiable)
For cases under USD 10,000, the legal cost can exceed expected recovery — at that level, the bank recall path and police report on your own (or with sourcing agent help) is usually more cost-effective.
What "Recovery" Actually Looks Like
Recovery from China supplier fraud rarely produces a clean refund. More common outcomes, ranked by frequency:
1. Partial recovery via negotiation under pressure of investigation. Once police are investigating and assets are frozen, the scammer (or their lawyer) often offers to return 40–80% of the deposit in exchange for case withdrawal. This is often the highest-yield outcome and frequently the fastest.
2. Partial recovery via civil judgment + asset enforcement. The Chinese court rules in your favor; enforcement officers (法警) recover the judgment amount from the supplier's accounts and assets. This works when the supplier still has assets in China; less effective when the supplier has dissipated.
3. Criminal conviction + restitution. The PSB completes investigation, prosecutor files charges, court convicts. Restitution is ordered as part of the criminal sentence. Slowest path (often 12–24 months), but produces full or near-full recovery when the funds haven't been dissipated.
4. Total loss. The supplier is genuinely judgment-proof: no traceable assets, identity may have been false from the start, funds long dissipated. This outcome is more common with truly anonymous "Alibaba storefront only" fraud where no real entity backs the storefront.
The published statistic frequently cited — that around half of well-documented China fraud cases produce some recovery within 12 months — applies to cases where the buyer documented properly, filed police early, and engaged Chinese counsel. For cases where the buyer did one or none of these, recovery rates are much lower.
Prevention: The Actions That Would Have Caught This
Most supplier fraud is preventable with verification work that takes 2–4 hours and costs nothing. The cases we see almost always missed at least three of these steps:
- Pull the business license and verify it on GSXT (the National Enterprise Credit Information Publicity System) — confirms the entity exists, is in good standing, and has the right business scope.
- Check the legal representative against China Judgments Online — confirms they're not on the judgment-debtor list.
- Run Tianyancha or Qichacha on the company name — surfaces lawsuits, equity structure, registered capital, and risk indicators.
- Send an NNN agreement before disclosing specifications. A factory that won't sign an NNN is a factory that doesn't intend to be held to commitments.
- Visit the factory (or have a sourcing agent visit) before the deposit on any first order above ~USD 10,000.
- Run a small test wire before the full deposit, to confirm the bank account is real and matches the entity.
- Use Trade Assurance or escrow for the first order if you're unable to do the in-person verification.
Every one of these steps would have caught the typical fraud pattern at the verification stage rather than at the missing-shipment stage. The next article in this series covers reading the Chinese business license in detail.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much money do I need to lose for Chinese police to investigate?
The criminal-fraud threshold under PRC law is regional. Common thresholds: RMB 5,000 (~USD 690) in Guangdong, RMB 10,000+ in some other provinces, with higher thresholds in major economic-crime divisions. Below the threshold, police treat it as a civil dispute. With clear evidence of intentional deception, even cases below threshold sometimes get investigated, but it's harder.
Should I tell other buyers about this supplier?
Yes — but carefully. Posting on Reddit, AliExpress complaint sites, or industry forums helps other buyers avoid the same trap. Be careful about defamation: stick to facts you can document, avoid characterizations that could be challenged in court if the supplier later sues you. The Chinese lawyer you engage can advise on how to publicize without creating new legal exposure.
Is Trade Assurance any help?
Trade Assurance is Alibaba's escrow-style protection. If you paid through it, file a Trade Assurance dispute immediately — this gives you Alibaba's internal investigation as a parallel track. Trade Assurance has well-documented limits (it doesn't always pay out even on legitimate cases), but it's free to use and worth running in parallel with police and bank channels.
What if the supplier offers to settle for half the amount and asks me to drop the case?
This is common, and the right answer depends on where you are in the process. If you're 7 days in with no police case yet, half is often genuinely the best you'll get and worth taking. If you're 60 days in with police investigation underway and assets frozen, you typically have leverage for more — your Chinese lawyer can advise on the realistic ceiling.
How long does recovery typically take?
Negotiated settlement under investigation pressure: 1–4 months. Civil judgment + enforcement: 6–18 months. Criminal conviction + restitution: 12–36 months. Set expectations accordingly — recovery is rarely fast.
Can I get my Chinese lawyer to take the case on a contingency basis?
Some can, particularly for larger cases (above USD 50,000–100,000) where the contingency arithmetic works out. Smaller cases typically require an upfront retainer. Contingency rates in China for commercial recovery work are typically 15–30% of recovered funds.
What if the supplier was on Alibaba — does Alibaba help?
Alibaba's response to fraud complaints has been criticized in published reports as inconsistent. They will typically suspend the supplier's storefront after a credible complaint, but they don't recover funds. The storefront suspension is useful evidence for your police report — it's an admission that the platform considered the conduct sufficient to warrant action.
Get Started Today
Let's Turn Your Sourcing Goals into RealityWeChat:+86 15157124615
WhatsApp:+86 15157124615
Address:Building 10 #39 Xiangyuan Road, Hangzhou, China




